Bottineau County vs. North Dakota
Comparative Trends Analysis:
Total Industry Earnings Growth and Change, 1969-2022
Introduction
Bottineau County vs. North Dakota
Bottineau County:
2022 Earnings = $344,926K
2022 Percent of State = 0.84%
North Dakota:
2022 Earnings = $41,039,957K
2022 Percent of U.S. = 0.27%
Industry earnings are incomes received by people who are directly involved with producing goods and services. Earnings, referred to also as "labor and proprietors income", include (1) wage and salary disbursements, (2) other labor income such as employer contributions to private retirement and medical insurance programs, and (3) the net incomes of proprietors (i.e., the owners of unincorporated enterprises).
In contrast to the more frequently cited employment data, earnings data more accurately reflect qualitative differences in labor's contributions toward the production of goods and services, namely the productivity differences reflected in variations in earnings per job. Earnings data, therefore, are better for comparing and tracking long-term trends and identifying short-run shifts in the level and composition of economic activity within and among counties.
Just like the employment data compiled by BEA, earnings data are reported on a place-of-work, or more accurately on a place-where-earned, basis.
Note: the BEA earnings data presented and discussed here in the context of comparing and assessing the economic growth and performance of county and regional economies are entirely separate and apart from--and should not be confused with--corporate earnings, which are compiled from the balance sheets of individual private corporations.
Bottineau County Total Industry Earnings, 1970-2022
Current vs. Constant Dollars (Millions)
Bottineau County Total Industry Earnings, 1970-2022
Current vs. Constant Dollars (Millions)
Figure 1.
Figure 1 depicts Bottineau County's annual total industry earnings over 1970-2022 in current and constant (2017) dollars. Constant dollar measurements remove the effects of inflation. They allow for comparison of changes in the real purchasing power of Bottineau County over time.
When measured in current dollars, Bottineau County's total industry earnings increased 1,520.89%, from $21M in 1970 to $345M in 2022. When measured in constant 2017 dollars to adjust for inflation, it advanced 176.09%, from $108M in 1970 to $297M in 2022.
Real Total Industry Earnings, 1969-2022 (Millions)
Real Total Industry Earnings, 1969-2022 (Millions)
Figure 2.
Figure 2 traces Bottineau County's and North Dakota's annual real total industry earnings for the period 1969-2022 to illustrate real total industry earnings patterns over time. During this 54-year period, Bottineau County's real total industry earnings rose from $119M in 1969 to $297M in 2022, for a net gain of $179M, or 150.65%. In comparison, North Dakota's real total industry earnings increased from $8,661M in 1969 to $35,366M in 2022, for a net gain of $26,705M, or 308.33%.
Real Total Industry Earnings Indices (1969=100): 1969-2022
Real Total Industry Earnings Indices (1969=100): 1969-2022
Figure 3.
Figure 3 portrays Bottineau County's real total industry earnings growth in a broader context by offering direct comparisons across time with North Dakota, the United States. The growth indices shown here express each region's real total industry earnings in 1969 as a base figure of 100, and the real total industry earningss in later years as a percentage of the 1969 base figure. This method allows for more direct comparison of differences in real total industry earnings growth between regions that may differ vastly in size.
Bottineau County's overall real total industry earnings growth was 150.65% over 1969-2022 trailed North Dakota's increase of 308.33%, and fell below the United States' increase of 278.59%.
Total Industry Earnings as a Percent of the North Dakota Total: 1969-2022
Total Industry Earnings as a Percent of the North Dakota Total: 1969-2022
Figure 4.
Another interesting and insightful way of contrasting the total industry earnings growth of Bottineau County is to trace its individual percentage contributions to North Dakota's statewide total industry earnings over time, as shown in Figure 4. A rising share means a region's total industry earnings grew faster, or declined less, than North Dakota's total industry earnings, while a declining share shows it grew more slowly.
In 1969, Bottineau County's total industry earnings totaled 1.37% of North Dakota's total industry earnings, while in 2022 it comprised 0.84% thereby yielding a -0.53% share-shift.
   
 
Total Industry Earnings Share-Shift
2022 vs. 1969
 
Share-
Shift*
 
2022
vs.
1969
-0.53%
=
0.84%
-
1.37%
 
   
Bottineau County Real Total Industry Earnings:
Annual Percent Change, 1970-2022
Bottineau County Real Total Industry Earnings:
Annual Percent Change, 1970-2022
Figure 5.
Figure 5 highlights the short-run pattern of Bottineau County's real total industry earnings growth by tracking the year-to-year percent change over 1970-2022. The average annual percent change for the entire 53-year period is also illustrated on this chart to provide a benchmark for gauging periods of relative high--and relative low--growth against the backdrop of the long-term average.
On average, Bottineau County's real total industry earnings grew at an annual rate of 6.50% over 1970-2022. The county posted its highest growth in 1973 (104.10%) and posted its lowest growth in 1999 (-43.95%). In 2022, Bottineau County's real total industry earnings grew by 36.36%
Bottineau County Real Total Industry Earnings:
Annual Percent Change and Decade Averages Over 1970-2022
Bottineau County Real Total Industry Earnings:
Annual Percent Change and Decade Averages Over 1970-2022
Figure 6.
Over the past five decades some counties have experienced extreme swings in growth, and often such swings have tended to coincide with the decades themselves. Figure 6 again depicts the annual percent change in Bottineau County's real total industry earnings since 1970, but this time they are displayed with average growth rates for the decade of the 1970s, 1980s, 1990s, 2000s, 2010s, and 2020-2022.
During the 1970s, Bottineau County's annual real total industry earnings growth rate averaged 5.43%. It averaged 5.65% throughout the 1980s, 1.14% throughout the 1990s, 17.30% in the 2000s, 0.55% during the 2010s, 14.56% thus far this decade (2020-2022).
Real Total Industry Earnings Growth:
Average Annual Percent Change by Decade
Real Total Industry Earnings Growth:
Average Annual Percent Change by Decade
Figure 7.
Figure 7 compares the decade average growth rates for Bottineau County noted in the previous graph with the corresponding decade averages for North Dakota and the nation. As the chart reveals, Bottineau County's average annual real total industry earnings growth outpaced North Dakota's average in the 1970s (5.43% vs. 4.68%), registered above North Dakota's average in the 1980s (5.65% vs. 0.07%), fell below North Dakota's average in the 1990s (1.14% vs. 3.45%), led North Dakota's average throughout the 2000s (17.30% vs. 3.77%), fell below North Dakota's average throughout the 2010s (0.55% vs. 3.89%), and surpassed North Dakota's average over the 3 year period of the current decade, 2020-2022 (14.56% vs. 2.25%).
Finally, relative to nationwide real total industry earnings growth trends, Bottineau County led the nation in the 1970s (5.43% vs. 3.13%), outpaced the nation during the 1980s (5.65% vs. 2.62%), fell under the nation in the 1990s (1.14% vs. 3.43%), registered above the nation throughout the 2000s (17.30% vs. 1.47%), trailed the nation over the 2010s (0.55% vs. 2.53%), and surpassed the nation over 2020-2022 (14.56% vs. 1.48%).
   
 
Real* Total Industry Earnings Growth:
Average Annual Percent Change
 
 
 
6.50
5.43
5.65
1.14
17.30
0.55
14.56
36.36
 
3.12
4.68
0.07
3.45
3.77
3.89
2.25
4.89
 
2.57
3.13
2.62
3.43
1.47
2.53
1.48
0.05
 
   

Interactive TableTip: To augment your analysis click on the column headers in the following table to rank and/or sort the data.

   
 
Bottineau County:
Total Industry Earnings, 1969-2022
 
1969
 
22,393
0.189
118,588
100.0
N
1.37
1970
 
21,280
0.198
107,660
90.8
-9.22
1.25
1971
 
26,141
0.206
126,867
107.0
17.84
1.33
1972
 
34,451
0.213
161,681
136.3
27.44
1.45
1973
 
74,098
0.225
329,984
278.3
104.10
2.15
1974
 
53,916
0.248
217,465
183.4
-34.10
1.62
1975
 
49,861
0.269
185,633
156.5
-14.64
1.47
1976
 
39,182
0.283
138,291
116.6
-25.50
1.21
1977
 
34,341
0.302
113,802
96.0
-17.71
1.05
1978
 
54,257
0.323
168,103
141.8
47.72
1.27
1979
 
34,509
0.351
98,196
82.8
-41.59
0.80
1980
 
23,876
0.389
61,334
51.7
-37.54
0.63
1981
 
43,660
0.424
102,935
86.8
67.83
0.87
1982
 
46,563
0.448
104,003
87.7
1.04
0.89
1983
 
56,194
0.467
120,392
101.5
15.76
1.02
1984
 
54,525
0.484
112,564
94.9
-6.50
0.91
1985
 
75,063
0.501
149,743
126.3
33.03
1.22
1986
 
68,524
0.512
133,786
112.8
-10.66
1.10
1987
 
56,505
0.528
107,013
90.2
-20.01
0.87
1988
 
40,290
0.549
73,435
61.9
-31.38
0.68
1989
 
60,944
0.573
106,432
89.7
44.93
0.91
1990
 
73,363
0.598
122,732
103.5
15.31
1.00
1991
 
56,960
0.618
92,207
77.8
-24.87
0.75
1992
 
78,708
0.634
124,106
104.7
34.59
0.93
1993
 
86,273
0.650
132,728
111.9
6.95
1.02
1994
 
91,964
0.664
138,592
116.9
4.42
0.98
1995
 
73,725
0.678
108,813
91.8
-21.49
0.80
1996
 
111,457
0.692
161,058
135.8
48.01
1.05
1997
 
66,824
0.704
94,911
80.0
-41.07
0.66
1998
 
89,918
0.710
126,704
106.8
33.50
0.80
1999
 
51,136
0.720
71,021
59.9
-43.95
0.44
2000
 
104,046
0.738
140,942
118.8
98.45
0.83
2001
 
90,680
0.753
120,422
101.5
-14.56
0.71
2002
 
93,950
0.763
123,147
103.8
2.26
0.71
2003
 
128,977
0.779
165,580
139.6
34.46
0.88
2004
 
87,852
0.798
110,053
92.8
-33.53
0.58
2005
 
108,456
0.821
132,059
111.4
20.00
0.68
2006
 
102,430
0.844
121,305
102.3
-8.14
0.61
2007
 
153,104
0.866
176,780
149.1
45.73
0.83
2008
 
208,694
0.892
234,041
197.4
32.39
1.02
2009
 
199,584
0.889
224,451
189.3
-4.10
0.97
2010
 
191,259
0.905
211,303
178.2
-5.86
0.83
2011
 
205,911
0.928
221,877
187.1
5.00
0.79
2012
 
302,270
0.945
319,747
269.6
44.11
0.97
2013
 
283,138
0.958
295,610
249.3
-7.55
0.89
2014
 
239,824
0.971
246,933
208.2
-16.47
0.71
2015
 
189,195
0.973
194,447
164.0
-21.26
0.58
2016
 
178,431
0.983
181,546
153.1
-6.63
0.58
2017
 
183,827
1.000
183,827
155.0
1.26
0.59
2018
 
225,208
1.020
220,690
186.1
20.05
0.68
2019
 
212,074
1.035
204,877
172.8
-7.17
0.62
2020
 
244,375
1.046
233,550
196.9
14.00
0.70
2021
 
237,609
1.090
217,988
183.8
-6.66
0.65
2022
 
344,926
1.160
297,240
250.6
36.36
0.84
Source: Calculations by the North Dakota Regional Economic Analysis Project (ND-REAP)
with data provided by the U.S. Department of Commerce, Bureau of Economic Analysis
November 2023
REAP_PI_CA1400_1200_PSN
 
   

Interactive TableTip: To augment your analysis click on the column headers in the following table to rank and/or sort the data.

   
 
North Dakota:
Total Industry Earnings, 1969-2022
 
1969
 
1,635,476
0.189
8,661,103
100.0
N
0.25
1970
 
1,697,577
0.198
8,588,369
99.2
-0.84
0.24
1971
 
1,959,279
0.206
9,508,755
109.8
10.72
0.26
1972
 
2,373,485
0.213
11,138,938
128.6
17.14
0.29
1973
 
3,449,296
0.225
15,360,926
177.4
37.90
0.38
1974
 
3,326,785
0.248
13,418,243
154.9
-12.65
0.33
1975
 
3,384,488
0.269
12,600,477
145.5
-6.09
0.32
1976
 
3,250,475
0.283
11,472,400
132.5
-8.95
0.28
1977
 
3,277,555
0.302
10,861,463
125.4
-5.33
0.25
1978
 
4,284,296
0.323
13,273,937
153.3
22.21
0.29
1979
 
4,324,493
0.351
12,305,418
142.1
-7.30
0.26
1980
 
3,766,068
0.389
9,674,445
111.7
-21.38
0.21
1981
 
5,008,975
0.424
11,809,442
136.4
22.07
0.26
1982
 
5,209,040
0.448
11,634,853
134.3
-1.48
0.25
1983
 
5,528,819
0.467
11,845,100
136.8
1.81
0.25
1984
 
5,973,109
0.484
12,331,198
142.4
4.10
0.25
1985
 
6,151,885
0.501
12,272,353
141.7
-0.48
0.24
1986
 
6,202,601
0.512
12,109,961
139.8
-1.32
0.22
1987
 
6,524,523
0.528
12,356,583
142.7
2.04
0.22
1988
 
5,923,751
0.549
10,796,958
124.7
-12.62
0.18
1989
 
6,675,182
0.573
11,657,467
134.6
7.97
0.19
1990
 
7,363,324
0.598
12,318,401
142.2
5.67
0.20
1991
 
7,550,161
0.618
12,222,231
141.1
-0.78
0.20
1992
 
8,446,587
0.634
13,318,491
153.8
8.97
0.21
1993
 
8,499,799
0.650
13,076,614
151.0
-1.82
0.20
1994
 
9,421,916
0.664
14,199,042
163.9
8.58
0.21
1995
 
9,215,390
0.678
13,601,249
157.0
-4.21
0.20
1996
 
10,588,494
0.692
15,300,629
176.7
12.49
0.21
1997
 
10,069,888
0.704
14,302,396
165.1
-6.52
0.19
1998
 
11,295,046
0.710
15,915,913
183.8
11.28
0.20
1999
 
11,554,251
0.720
16,047,348
185.3
0.83
0.19
2000
 
12,600,120
0.738
17,068,245
197.1
6.36
0.19
2001
 
12,856,596
0.753
17,073,379
197.1
0.03
0.19
2002
 
13,207,378
0.763
17,311,843
199.9
1.40
0.19
2003
 
14,736,799
0.779
18,919,043
218.4
9.28
0.20
2004
 
15,091,828
0.798
18,905,669
218.3
-0.07
0.20
2005
 
16,029,789
0.821
19,518,294
225.4
3.24
0.20
2006
 
16,675,653
0.844
19,748,523
228.0
1.18
0.20
2007
 
18,468,147
0.866
21,324,081
246.2
7.98
0.21
2008
 
20,476,941
0.892
22,963,935
265.1
7.69
0.23
2009
 
20,545,958
0.889
23,105,856
266.8
0.62
0.24
2010
 
23,004,671
0.905
25,415,594
293.4
10.00
0.25
2011
 
25,915,118
0.928
27,924,570
322.4
9.87
0.27
2012
 
31,300,083
0.945
33,109,868
382.3
18.57
0.32
2013
 
31,731,678
0.958
33,129,408
382.5
0.06
0.31
2014
 
33,780,051
0.971
34,781,408
401.6
4.99
0.32
2015
 
32,357,195
0.973
33,255,424
384.0
-4.39
0.29
2016
 
30,852,577
0.983
31,391,251
362.4
-5.61
0.27
2017
 
31,307,802
1.000
31,307,802
361.5
-0.27
0.26
2018
 
33,029,524
1.020
32,366,972
373.7
3.38
0.27
2019
 
34,257,893
1.035
33,095,257
382.1
2.25
0.26
2020
 
34,840,100
1.046
33,296,794
384.4
0.61
0.26
2021
 
36,752,082
1.090
33,717,197
389.3
1.26
0.26
2022
 
41,039,957
1.160
35,366,163
408.3
4.89
0.27
Source: Calculations by the North Dakota Regional Economic Analysis Project (ND-REAP)
with data provided by the U.S. Department of Commerce, Bureau of Economic Analysis
November 2023
REAP_PI_CA1400_1200_PSN
 
   

Interactive TableTip: To augment your analysis click on the column headers in the following table to rank and/or sort the data.

   
 
United States:
Total Industry Earnings, 1969-2022
 
1969
 
653,665,000
0.189
3,461,658,635
100.0
N
1970
 
693,352,000
0.198
3,507,801,275
101.3
1.33
1971
 
742,094,000
0.206
3,601,523,902
104.0
2.67
1972
 
819,646,000
0.213
3,846,658,532
111.1
6.81
1973
 
918,964,000
0.225
4,092,469,383
118.2
6.39
1974
 
993,909,000
0.248
4,008,829,105
115.8
-2.04
1975
 
1,059,492,000
0.269
3,944,497,394
113.9
-1.60
1976
 
1,173,271,000
0.283
4,141,005,188
119.6
4.98
1977
 
1,303,767,000
0.302
4,320,542,816
124.8
4.34
1978
 
1,476,080,000
0.323
4,573,305,242
132.1
5.85
1979
 
1,648,363,000
0.351
4,690,444,754
135.5
2.56
1980
 
1,784,597,000
0.389
4,584,353,165
132.4
-2.26
1981
 
1,961,173,000
0.424
4,623,772,250
133.6
0.86
1982
 
2,053,729,000
0.448
4,587,185,902
132.5
-0.79
1983
 
2,188,018,000
0.467
4,687,672,466
135.4
2.19
1984
 
2,432,402,000
0.484
5,021,577,654
145.1
7.12
1985
 
2,615,791,000
0.501
5,218,223,348
150.7
3.92
1986
 
2,786,901,000
0.512
5,441,146,840
157.2
4.27
1987
 
2,996,000,000
0.528
5,674,027,499
163.9
4.28
1988
 
3,259,979,000
0.549
5,941,819,010
171.6
4.72
1989
 
3,467,027,000
0.573
6,054,778,994
174.9
1.90
1990
 
3,679,460,000
0.598
6,155,516,520
177.8
1.66
1991
 
3,789,428,000
0.618
6,134,341,309
177.2
-0.34
1992
 
4,059,023,000
0.634
6,400,225,481
184.9
4.33
1993
 
4,237,437,000
0.650
6,519,133,846
188.3
1.86
1994
 
4,456,948,000
0.664
6,716,721,924
194.0
3.03
1995
 
4,674,849,000
0.678
6,899,738,761
199.3
2.72
1996
 
4,956,180,000
0.692
7,161,799,344
206.9
3.80
1997
 
5,288,047,000
0.704
7,510,683,597
217.0
4.87
1998
 
5,707,014,000
0.710
8,041,785,619
232.3
7.07
1999
 
6,098,042,000
0.720
8,469,385,147
244.7
5.32
2000
 
6,598,743,000
0.738
8,938,721,519
258.2
5.54
2001
 
6,865,291,000
0.753
9,117,010,172
263.4
1.99
2002
 
7,001,002,000
0.763
9,176,707,606
265.1
0.65
2003
 
7,243,377,000
0.779
9,299,017,896
268.6
1.33
2004
 
7,674,785,000
0.798
9,614,272,113
277.7
3.39
2005
 
8,039,238,000
0.821
9,788,788,097
282.8
1.82
2006
 
8,519,349,000
0.844
10,089,233,775
291.5
3.07
2007
 
8,866,261,000
0.866
10,237,349,175
295.7
1.47
2008
 
9,014,085,000
0.892
10,108,876,304
292.0
-1.25
2009
 
8,688,913,000
0.889
9,771,497,172
282.3
-3.34
2010
 
9,023,916,000
0.905
9,969,635,637
288.0
2.03
2011
 
9,444,387,000
0.928
10,176,702,513
294.0
2.08
2012
 
9,854,834,000
0.945
10,424,645,101
301.1
2.44
2013
 
10,180,570,000
0.958
10,629,007,841
307.0
1.96
2014
 
10,613,874,000
0.971
10,928,505,678
315.7
2.82
2015
 
11,039,821,000
0.973
11,346,284,134
327.8
3.82
2016
 
11,311,477,000
0.983
11,508,970,941
332.5
1.43
2017
 
11,848,205,000
1.000
11,848,205,000
342.3
2.95
2018
 
12,438,590,000
1.020
12,189,079,542
352.1
2.88
2019
 
12,989,097,000
1.035
12,548,276,062
362.5
2.95
2020
 
13,158,025,000
1.046
12,575,166,053
363.3
0.21
2021
 
14,278,043,000
1.090
13,099,001,844
378.4
4.17
2022
 
15,207,952,000
1.160
13,105,445,395
378.6
0.05
Source: Calculations by the North Dakota Regional Economic Analysis Project (ND-REAP)
with data provided by the U.S. Department of Commerce, Bureau of Economic Analysis
November 2023
REAP_PI_CA1400_1200_PN
 
   
Copyright © 2023. Pacific Northwest Regional Economic Analysis Project (PNREAP). All Rights Reserved.

Please stay tuned...
while your request is processing:

Please wait while your request is being processed...
To offer the most comprehensive set of interactive options in support of your research, ND-REAP calculates and crunches most of the data and generates the narrative and graphic analysis on demand in response to your request.
Your request will soon be available.
Just a few more seconds....Your request has been generated and is now loading the results.